# Understanding the Gaps in Carbon Offset Calculations
Written on
Chapter 1: The Importance of Sustainability
Sustainability is not just an ideal; it’s a necessity for our survival. The evidence is undeniable: our planet is experiencing significant warming, primarily due to human activities. This warming comes with additional challenges, including ocean acidification and the loss of vital species that play a crucial role in our ecosystems.
The climate crisis can be overwhelming. Its gradual nature makes it hard to notice until it’s too late, similar to watching a sunset. The sun sets so slowly that we often fail to see it happen until darkness envelops us, making it impossible to bring back the light.
Fortunately, society is beginning to recognize the urgency of our climate situation. Our reliance on fossil fuels and consumption-driven lifestyles is accelerating the decline of our planet's climate stability. Despite numerous international agreements aimed at reversing this trend, our actions often fall short. Instead, we find ourselves observing the gradual deterioration of our climate, hoping to discover ways to reverse this trend. One method we use to monitor our impact is through calculating carbon footprints.
The carbon footprint represents the amount of carbon dioxide each person emits during various activities. It is derived from estimates based on scientific research about human consumption and emissions. However, understanding and utilizing this number effectively remains a challenge.
If not contextualized, the carbon footprint can become an abstract, intimidating figure. It typically conveys a negative connotation, as it’s rare for anyone to have a zero or negative carbon footprint in today’s world.
To illustrate this, let’s consider my experience as I travel from London to Coventry. I’m taking a train to meet friends and attend a conference on science and religion—a topic I frequently write about.
I booked my journey using Trainline, a popular UK app that simplifies ticket purchases and route planning. Recently, Trainline introduced a feature that calculates carbon emissions for each journey. For my trip, I had the option of two trains: one that emits 7.8 kg of CO2 per passenger over 3 hours and 38 minutes, and another that emits 7.6 kg over a slightly shorter time of 3 hours and 25 minutes.
While it's great to know my CO2 emissions for this trip, several questions arise: What does it mean to emit 7.6 kg of CO2? The train isn’t full, so how does this affect my individual responsibility for that emission? How does this compare to other trains? Is this average, or does it run efficiently? How does one visualize 7.6 kg of CO2? Without a frame of reference, it’s hard to grasp the significance of this number.
For instance, what would the emissions be if I traveled by plane or car? The comparison is unclear. Even my food choices, such as the vegan burger I purchased at a station, raise questions about their carbon impact. What ingredients were used, and where did they come from?
The main issue with carbon footprint calculators lies in their inability to provide meaningful context. They can track emissions, but they often fail to deliver accurate comparisons or insights into individual behaviors. For these tools to be truly effective, they need to present both the carbon output and a comparative analysis.
We should strive to understand how much carbon we might have saved on a given day compared to our past habits. Have our choices been ethical and sustainable? While we may not have all the answers, these are essential questions to consider. Perhaps we need to cultivate a deeper sense of responsibility toward our environment, rather than relying solely on cold data. Simply knowing that I emitted 7.6 kg of CO2 today through my train journey doesn’t foster a sense of environmental accountability; instead, it often evokes guilt and discourages action.
Chapter 2: Exploring Carbon Offset Methods
The first video discusses NASA's ARSET program, focusing on various techniques and methods for carbon estimation, emphasizing the importance of understanding carbon emissions in relation to climate change.
The second video provides a tutorial on calculating carbon credits using Excel, illustrating how individuals and organizations can assess their carbon impact effectively.