Navigating the Challenge of a Spending Ban: Insights and Reflections
Written on
Chapter 1: The Unexpected Difficulty of a Spending Ban
Gently running my fingers over the array of jackets in a quaint pop-up shop, I find myself enjoying the rich autumn-winter hues more out of habit than intent. The shop's owner, who is as stylishly dressed as the merchandise, beams with pride as she shares, "I carefully select items that align perfectly." However, rather than feeling delighted, I find the curated selection of second-hand clothing all the more enticing—an upscale shop offering deals too good to resist.
I shove my hands back into the pockets of my thick winter coat and focus on my daughter, who is excitedly trying on clothes. "I’ve placed myself under a personal spending restriction," I mention to the owner, feeling the need to justify my lack of browsing. "It’s proving to be more challenging than I anticipated."
She chuckles, "I noticed you kept your hands tucked away."
"I'm really trying to stick to my commitment, but your shop is certainly a temptation."
The Challenge Beyond 30 Days
Throughout the years, I’ve often engaged in various challenges lasting around 30 days, like quitting sugar or writing extensively. These short periods allow for self-reflection, even though research suggests a longer duration—around 66 days—might be more effective for forming lasting habits. I've learned quite a bit about myself through these 30-day challenges.
However, this time, my commitment is indefinite. Motivated by a savings goal set in April, I decided to refrain from personal purchases until I reach that target. Although I generally don’t splurge, I assumed this spending ban would be easy. After all, what would I truly miss? A few books? Some winter attire? It didn’t appear to be a significant challenge at all.
I scribbled my financial target on a post-it note and stuck it on my dresser, treating it as a contract with myself. A few months in, it became clear that this challenge would be more difficult and prolonged than I had first thought.
Section 1.1: The Temptation of a Bargain
In the store, my hands once again crept from my pockets to grab a lovely summer top on the discount rack. The fabric felt soft against my fingers, and I recognized it as one of my favorite brands. My heart raced as I saw the price—originally marked at $49, now slashed to $10. What a steal!
I couldn't help but picture myself wearing it. Wouldn’t it be wise to snag such a bargain for summer?
My daughter chimed in, "That's cute! You should totally buy it!"
I shook my head and returned it to the rack. "No, I really shouldn’t."
She suggested, "Just buy it for me, and I’ll gift it back to you later. Then it wouldn’t count as a cheat."
"I still consider that cheating," I replied, moving away but unable to shake off thoughts of the top. "It’ll be gone by summer, and you’ll regret not buying it," my mind insisted. Just $10! That's practically nothing.
"We should probably head out," I finally said, but as we drove home, that familiar weight in my stomach told me I had made a misstep.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Importance of Self-Honesty
As part of my spending ban, I’ve been diligently documenting every purchase and impulse buy. I’ve established rules for what I can and cannot buy, but I’ve come to realize that I haven’t been entirely honest about my spending habits.
I consider myself quite frugal, yet there are moments throughout the week when I feel the urge to make impulse purchases—temptations I likely would have succumbed to before starting the ban. In those moments, buying something small gave me an instant rush of happiness. The thought of forgoing a purchase, like the summer top, lingered in my mind for hours.
It’s all too easy to deceive myself about spending when it’s under $20. It feels insignificant, as though it doesn’t count. Yet, there were times in my life when $20 meant a lot—like during my divorce, when it could cover gas or meals for a week. Now, in a more stable position, I sometimes feel entitled to indulge. And if a book or a nice top brings joy, why not buy it? I don’t judge others for spending their hard-earned money however they choose.
What fascinates me is how we let small expenses slip by unnoticed.
All those minor purchases accumulate and can derail our long-term savings goals. We often buy mindlessly for that quick dopamine fix, especially when the "pain of paying" is minimal.
Section 1.2: Raising the Pain of Paying
Books are among my favorite indulgences. Before this spending ban, I could easily rack up over $60 on eBooks without a second thought. I had to sift through my account records to realize just how much I had spent. eBooks became a fun purchase that didn’t feel like spending at all—low-cost, digital, and charged with a single click, making the pain of paying nearly nonexistent.
But once I tallied up my expenses and wrote them down, that $60 felt significantly more painful.
Financial journalist Joe Pinsker shared in the Atlantic how he curbed his spending by increasing his awareness of costs. His simple rule was to log every purchase on his phone, detailing the price and item. By doing so, he heightened his sense of the "pain of paying," particularly with credit cards.
Though he was not a frequent shopper, this practice reduced his spending by about 10–15%.
While becoming more aware of our expenditures is a good start, as Pinsker noted, it may not be a sustainable long-term solution. Will we really keep track of every expense indefinitely? Unlikely. The larger question is whether we’re being truthful with ourselves. It’s perfectly acceptable to spend on things we enjoy, but are we purchasing more than necessary? Are we living beyond our means, jeopardizing our future financial wellbeing?
Chapter 2: A Turning Point in Perspective
This morning, I reflected on that delightful summer top I chose not to buy yesterday. Without the adrenaline of impulse shopping, my thoughts became clearer. It wasn’t the perfect item after all. Why was I so drawn to it? As I pondered, it became apparent that the brand and the low price were the primary reasons for my desire.
In reality, I possess enough summer attire. This seems to be the recurring theme of my challenge—I have more than enough. Many of us in the West have an abundance. Our closets and garages are overflowing, yet consumer culture constantly urges us to acquire more.
I am a quarter of the way toward my savings goal, and the more I reflect on my potential purchases, the more I recognize how unnecessary they often are. Resisting the allure of pretty items and the temptation of discounted eBooks is tougher than I anticipated, but there is a surprising calm that comes with letting those feelings pass and appreciating what I already have.
The first video, "Why We Can't Stop Shopping & I'm Going on a Shopping Ban for 3 Months," delves into the psychology behind shopping habits and the challenges of maintaining a spending ban.
The second video, "The Full Story of MrBeast," provides insights into the life of a prominent figure in the YouTube community and how financial decisions can shape one's journey.