Understanding the Spread of Respiratory Viruses: A New Perspective
Written on
Chapter 1: Misconceptions in Disease Transmission
The way infectious diseases transfer from person to person is crucial. Misunderstanding this can hinder our ability to control outbreaks and may exacerbate the situation. In the 19th century, for instance, Londoners believed that cholera was spread through "bad air," leading them to dump sewage into the Thames River, which only worsened the outbreak. The true mode of transmission was through contaminated food and water.
Similar mistakes have been made regarding measles and tuberculosis, which are aerosol infections mistakenly thought to be spread through larger droplets. Most recently, the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), responsible for the Covid-19 pandemic, has faced the same misinterpretation.
Understanding Respiratory Viruses - This video provides an in-depth look at respiratory viruses, their modes of transmission, and how we can better understand their spread.
Section 1.1: Droplet vs. Aerosol Transmission
In July 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) claimed that SARS-CoV-2 was transmitted via respiratory droplets emitted through sneezing and coughing, typically traveling less than 1 meter. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) followed suit, recognizing aerosol transmission only later, in October 2020, as a secondary route.
By April and May 2021, both organizations finally acknowledged aerosols as a primary transmission method. The CDC has since clarified that surface transmission is not the main route for SARS-CoV-2, although this update initially went unnoticed.
Droplets are large and heavy, falling quickly to the ground, while aerosols are smaller, lighter particles that can linger in the air, especially in poorly ventilated spaces. Aerosols can travel much farther—up to 8 meters compared to less than 1 meter for droplets—though they disperse rapidly outdoors.
This explains the phenomenon of superspreader events, which have predominantly occurred indoors. A review of over 2,000 such incidents has not recorded any happening outdoors, despite the fact that close-contact droplet transmission can still occur outside, albeit at significantly reduced risk.
Transmission of Respiratory Infectious Diseases - This video discusses the various ways respiratory infections can be transmitted and the implications for public health.
Section 1.2: The Impact of Misunderstanding Transmission
In early 2020, the focus was heavily on droplet transmission. People religiously disinfected surfaces and maintained physical distance, often overlooking the importance of masks and good ventilation. The CDC and WHO initially deemed masks unnecessary if physical distancing was observed.
As we learned, these approaches were misguided, and the consequences have been severe, with Covid-19 cases and fatalities soaring. Experts like Dr. Kevin P. Fennelly have criticized the overemphasis on surface disinfection, stating that it diverts critical resources from addressing airborne transmission.
By late 2020, global disinfectant sales increased by over 30%, amounting to around $4.5 billion. In New York City, vast sums were spent on cleaning public transport, yet infections continued to surge. Even in India, where Covid-19 has had a devastating impact, efforts to disinfect surfaces have overshadowed more pressing needs, such as ensuring adequate oxygen supply in hospitals.
Chapter 2: Acknowledging Airborne Spread
In July 2020, 239 scientists urged the WHO to recognize the evidence supporting aerosol transmission of respiratory viruses, including SARS-CoV-2. However, the organization was slow to accept this viewpoint.
Numerous studies have since reinforced the idea that aerosol transmission is a significant factor. For example, live SARS-CoV-2 has been detected in air samples from hospital rooms and vehicles. Research has shown that asymptomatic individuals can still spread the virus, further underscoring the importance of aerosols in transmission.
It took over a year for the WHO and CDC to acknowledge the role of aerosols, partly due to resistance from some scientists who clung to outdated beliefs. The precautionary principle also contributed to the delay, as the WHO was reluctant to challenge established views without overwhelming evidence.
Section 2.1: The Flawed Focus on Fomite Transmission
Authorities once emphasized droplet and fomite transmission, but the evidence was primarily drawn from other viruses, not SARS-CoV-2. Dr. Benedetta Allegranzi from the WHO admitted that direct fomite transmission had not been clearly demonstrated for SARS-CoV-2.
Critics like Dr. Emanuel Goldman have argued that most studies on fomite transmission lack real-world applicability. He posited that fomite transmission is a minor component of the pandemic, advocating for routine hygiene over extensive disinfecting efforts.
A systematic review of 64 studies showed no successful recovery of live SARS-CoV-2 from surfaces, suggesting that the virus does not survive long enough to pose a significant risk via fomite transmission.
In summary, we need to reevaluate our understanding of how respiratory viruses spread. It appears that many respiratory infections, including SARS-CoV-2, primarily transmit through the air rather than surfaces. As we move forward, prioritizing mask-wearing, improving indoor air quality, and vaccination should take precedence over unnecessary fears of touching surfaces.
If you found this information valuable, consider subscribing to my Medium email list. Your support can help sustain science writing and public health education.